The Backstreets Boys' Black & Blue
- Ben Domenech National Review contributing editor
- 2001 3 Jan
Black & Blue has been hyped and rehyped for much of the past year. After N'SYNC's No Strings Attached shattered the Backstreets' numbers, this album was supposed to reestablish the Boys as the true princes of pop balladry and teenybopper adoration. Rolling Stone magazine put the Backstreet Boys on the cover not once, but twice in the past year, and pronounced I Want it That Way as one of the 10 greatest pop songs of all time. The magazine even sparked a little controversy in the group: When their photographers asked the Boys to pose in a photo spread surrounded by nude models, Brian Littrell (who, along with cousin Kevin Richardson, forms the core of the group) refused to go along. He's married, and Baptist (People magazine once called him a "prude"). In the end, only Kevin, A.J., Howie, and Nick appeared with the unclothed girls; the magazine was forced to include a separate picture of Brian, alone, smiling, juggling in a different room.
The problem with the ad campaigns, MTV appearances, and PR hype is, quite simply, this: Black & Blue is a perfectly conventional pop record. There are high points, and low. But coming on the heels of Millennium - quite possibly the best boy-band release of the '90s - this album is a C+, nothing special, disappointingly average.
The songs are slightly more musically mature than the Backstreets' previous work, with plenty of Swedish pop influences and rhythm hooks. The subject matter is still as juvenile as before, though there's little on this album that would offend: Shining Star has some rather sensual lyrics, but mostly it's just standard pop fare: Get Another Boyfriend, Not for Me, and I Promise You (With Everything I Am) could all be N'SYNC or 98 Degrees songs, and there'd be little change in delivery or styling. There are some standouts - The Answer to Our Life and Shape of My Heart are both decent songs.
There's nothing on this record, though, that really impresses the listener, nothing original, nothing that makes you want to sing along, dance, or even memorize the lyrics (a la I Want it That Way). Perhaps that's due to the pop scene's incestuous production relationships - the Backstreets' manager, Louis Pearlman, is also the man to thank (or blame) for N'SYNC and Britney Spears. Black & Blue is an average pop album in so many respects, it might be time to start wondering if the Backstreet Boys are just an average pop group, after all.
Crosswalk.com Music Editor Matt Turner lists his picks for top 10 Christian albums of 2000. Do you agree with his list?
If you like the Backstreet Boys you might also like the Christian band Plus One.