The writers’ strike ended several days ago, in time to salvage this year’s Oscars telecast. This matters to the industry, but the buzz on the telecast is that it may score record-low ratings, the victim of the network TV’s supposedly slow slide into irrelevancy (don’t tell that to the near record number of viewers for last month’s Super Bowl, broadcast on network TV).
Then there’s the tone of this year’s Best Picture nominees. Can you say “downbeat”? With the exception of “Juno”—which has developed into a $100-million-plus hit—the major nominees are gloomy.
All we ask is that the show entertains, maybe even makes us laugh. If anyone can do that, it’s Oscar host Jon Stewart. So … here we go.
8:32—First joke: “make-up sex.” Oooo-kay. Maybe he’s just warming up. Ah, there it is! A crack about this year’s “psychopathic” Best Picture nominees.
8:35—First Clinton joke. The Jewish “Atonement” joke gets some laughs—including a hearty one from me. A “Norbit” joke scores! And with a decent lawyer joke, Stewart is officially on a roll.
Monologue over. It took a while for Stewart to warm up, but this outing turned out better than his last.
8:42—BEST COSTUME DESIGN
Winner: “
8:52—BEST ANIMATED FEATURE
Presenter Steve Carell reminds us of how funny he can be.
Winner: “Ratatouille”
8:56—BEST MAKEUP
Winner: “La Vie en Rose” Great choice! Not to underrate Marion Cotillard’s performance, but the makeup was superb.
9:07—BEST VISUAL EFFECTS
Winner: “The Golden Compass”! I was sure it would go to “Transformers.” The four winners are, again, a model in brevity when it comes to their acceptance speech.
My wife comments about presenter Cate Blanchett’s hair: “I’m disappointed. It looks like something I’d wake up in.”
Winner: “Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street.” Well deserved. Dante Ferreti’s Italian accent is thick.
“But look at her hair!” my wife exclaims, still distracted by Blanchett. “Her dress looks great, but look at her hair!”
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Winner: Javier Bardem, “No Country for Old Men” Not unexpected, but maybe a sign of a big night for “No Country.” Beautiful reaction shot from Bardem’s mother in the audience.
9:22—Biggest laugh yet for the Oscar salutes to binoculars and periscopes, followed by a salute to bad dreams. These are the best laughs the Oscar broadcast has seen in years, monologues included.
9:26—The second Best Song nominees to be performed is, like Amy Adams’ performance of the first nominee, well executed. These presentations can be dreary, but so far, this year’s Best Song performances have been exciting.
9:28— BEST SHORT FILM
Owen Wilson presents. It’s good to see Owen in front of a camera again.
Winner: “Les Mozart des Pickpockets”
Another foreign-language acceptance speech. Not bad!
BEST ANIMATED SHORT FILM
Jerry Seinfeld’s bee character isn’t very funny.
Winner: “Peter and the Wolf”
9:35—BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Winner: Tilda Swinton, “Michael Clayton.”
My wife says, “Now that is the ugliest dress in Oscar history. It looks like a gunny sack, a yard trash bag.” My wife is catty tonight. Look out!
9:46—BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
Winner: Joel and Ethan Coen, “No Country for Old Men”
BEST SOUND EDITING
Winner: “The Bourne Ultimatum”
No “No Country” momentum yet.
BEST SOUND MIXING
Winner: “The Bourne Ultimatum”
Big “Bourne” momentum! Could it take Best Picture later tonight?
No. It couldn’t. Because it wasn’t nominated in any major categories.
BEST ACTRESS
Already?! It’s “only”
Winner: Marion Cotillard, “La Vie en Rose”
Major surprise! “You truly rocked my life!” “Thank you life, thank you love. It is true there are some angels in this city.” What a great speech!
Instead, I get the montage of Best Picture winners—a reminder of how underwhelming so many of the choices have been over the years. Will this year’s winner be a proud addition to the canon, or a film that, years from now, makes viewers of a similar montage shrug their shoulders when a clip from it appears?
BEST FILM EDITING
Funny picture of Roderick Jaynes, editor for “No Country for Old Men”—a person who doesn’t exist.
Winner: “The Bourne Ultimatum”—which is cleaning up in the categories in which it’s nominated.
Long speech, but the guy’s nearly 100 years old and is more poised than most of the other presenters and award recipients tonight. Cut him some slack!
BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM
My wife has gone to bed, so no comment on Penelope Cruz’s dress. Me, I think Cruz is gorgeous, as always. She could wear a gunny sack, and I'd be fine with that.
Winner: “The Counterfeiters”
It’s the first Austrian film to win the Best Foreign Film Oscar.
The Oscar goes to “Falling Slowly,” from “Once”—a great song, a great movie moment, an outstanding film. Very, very gratifying.
BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY
Great work all around this year. Tough to pick a winner here.
Winner: Robert Elswit, “There Will Be Blood”
11:04—The “In Memorium” feature ends with a lingering shot of Heath Ledger. Ingmar Bergman, meanwhile, gets a two-second shot sandwiched between two other industry folks near the end of the segment, and only after the segment notes the passing of several
Winner: “Atonement”! But will it, like “
11:12—BEST DOCUMENTARY SHORT FEATURE
Presented from
Winner, “Freeheld”
That woman’s expression—shocked delight—as she heads to the podium says it all, doesn’t it?
BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE
Winner, “Taxi to the Dark Side”
11:20—OK, it’s been over an hour since I asked you to check in and see if I held to my notion that the show was well paced. And I had, until they just said that the Original Screenplay awards remain. Which means Best Director remains. And maybe another honorary Oscar, or a montage or two, before the Best Picture award. I’m hangin’ in.
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
Winner: “Juno”
You know things are strange when I notice how, ummm, strange a dress looks on someone. That leopard-print thing—don’t know what to say about that.
So “Juno” can’t be counted out as Best Picture.
11:29—BEST ACTOR
Winner: Daniel Day Lewis, “There Will Be Blood”
11:40—BEST DIRECTOR
Winner: Joel and Ethan Coen, “No Country for Old Men”
Only one more award to go.
11:45—BEST PICTURE
Hey, it’s 15 minutes before
Winner: “No Country for Old Men”
Big night for the Coen Brothers. An excellent film that forthrightly addresses evil, and the presence, or lack, of God in the lives of its characters. It’s a challenging film, but a dark one.