- reviewed by Russ Breimeier Copyright Christianity Today International
- 2008 1 Jul
- This Is Who I Am
- Slow Down
- Call My Name
- Run to You
- Let Me Love You
- I Will Always Be True
- Born Again
- Give Love
- Caught Up in Yourself
- Take It All
As one of Christian music's most popular bands since the mid '90s, it's well established that Third Day has subtly varied its sound from album to album. But the Southern rock that first established Third Day with their 1996 debut and 1999's
Skeptics, it's time to give Third Day another chance. After capping off their first ten years with a pair of greatest hits collections, the band decided it was time to push hard past their comfort zone. I've heard lead singer Mac Powell and the others say that they put more blood and sweat into their tenth studio album than any previous effort. It's not just hyperbole, it's a
Before we get ahead of ourselves, this album is not a complete reinvention for Third Day—there's plenty here that will sound familiar to fans and disenfranchised listeners alike. Instead, it might be best to view
Credit much of that to producer Howard Benson (P.O.D., Relient K), who helped Third Day beef up their sound while remaining true to it, ensuring that the songs were both memorable and meaningful. Anyone expecting something as trippy and creative as Wilco from Third Day has unrealistic expectations of the band. They've always been about accessible pop/rock with a Southern flavor, and in that
The real treat is hearing Third Day credibly rock out again, recapturing the energy of their live show along with the edge of their earlier efforts. That much is obvious from the opening track "This Is Who I Am," a grittier rocker that asks God to take us as we are and make us into something more. It's followed by "Slow Down," a decent rock anthem asking for God to pace our lives, improved that much more by the backing vocals of Chris Daughtry. But the real standout is "Otherside," an absolute blast of a Southern rocker featuring the blazing pedal steel of Robert Randolph, perfectly suited for this band in what is sure to be a highlight for their tour together this fall.
It's also nice to hear the band varying their sonic palette here and there. "I Will Always Be True" bears an enjoyably jangly pop/rock style similar to Tom Petty or Hootie & the Blowfish, and "Give Love" shows a folksy roots side not heard often enough from Third Day. The plea to God "Run to You" could be heard as another "Consuming Fire" with its 6/8 feel, but distinguishes itself thanks to the backing vocals of Flyleaf's Lacey Mosley.
Those who have enjoyed the band's pop ballads will also find plenty to like throughout. In the capable hands of Benson, a big AC-friendly radio single like "Call My Name" is elevated from becoming another "Cry Out to Jesus" thanks to smart hooks, a strong melody, and some of Powell's most impressive vocal work to date during the closing vamp, belting out notes I didn't know he was capable of. "Take It All" is another one that's sure to be a hit, for its melody, its guitar work (electric and acoustic), and its open expression of spiritual surrender. "Born Again" is also striking as a heartfelt expression of what it's like to experience a change from within, not to mention another duet vocal with Mosley.
But Third Day still relies too heavily on formulaic ballads when they could be rocking out more or trying other styles. "Let Me Love You" is fine as a song sharing God's plea to the brokenhearted, but we've heard plenty just like this from Third Day before. The same could be said of the title track, which smartly makes a distinction between asking God for something and asking for what he wants of us—but its "Show Me Your Glory" all over again, with a guitar lick lifted straight out of "The Space Between" by the Dave Matthews Band. For that matter, "Ready" has a bouncy shuffle that helps it stand out among the ballads on this album, but is too reminiscent of many other similar songs by Third Day over the years.
Familiarity isn't necessarily a bad thing, however, especially on a project this well crafted.