Home School...Or Else?
- Matt Friedeman, Ph.D. Agape Press
- 2005 17 May
Our educational delivery system in this country is in a mess. And, really, there is only one solution. You! Mr./Miss/Mrs. Parent -- you must homeschool. You must.
First, some research. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development has recently conducted a study to show, once again, that American kids feel good about their abilities but far underachieve in math when stacked up against 40 other countries of the world. And, to no one's surprise who has been a spectator of the dismal scene across the years, our "bang for buck" -- the money we spend on public schools compared to the results in terms of student achievement -- is the worst among the 41 nations studied.
This study only reflects other surveys of educational trends across the last five decades. We do well at coaching our underperforming kids on self-esteem (they actually think they are good at reading and math); but they can't read, add, or think adequately in comparison to their peers in other nations.
All the while, we are spending dramatically more on a paradigm that doesn't work. Over the past 30 years, average per-pupil expenditures for public, elementary, and secondary schools have nearly doubled, rising from $3,931 in 1971-1972 to $7,524 in 2001-2002, in constant dollars. Since 1960, per-pupil expenditures have almost tripled in constant dollars. And test scores? Down, a bit. Mostly flat.
So, the parent hopes, maybe college can fill the gaps left by the international joke of a public education system.
Wouldn't count on it.
A recent Zogby survey found that "contemporary college seniors scored on average little or no higher than the high-school graduates of a half-century ago on a series of 15 questions assessing general cultural knowledge." Oh, but they are learning something. Another survey found that 98 percent of our college and university seniors could identify Snoop Doggy Dogg, but only a third could tell you that Washington was the general at the battle of Yorktown.
And, knowing in their heart of hearts that something might be amiss, our educational establishment has responded -- with liberals, and liberal ideas. The New York Times recently reported that Democratic professors outnumber Republicans among academics by 7-to-1 in the humanities and social sciences. That ratio skyrockets to 28-to-1 and 30-to-1 in a separate study when talking about sociology and anthropology, respectively.
Here in Mississippi a few years ago, in a brilliant move of liberal thinking under an "education governor" whom the teacher unions swooned over, a computer was placed in every single classroom in the state. "Ready for the 21st century," was the jubilant chorus.
And now comes the study from the CESifo economic research organization in Munich that computers make kids dumber. The more computers there were in student's home, the worse the student's math performance. And those who used school computers several times a week performed "sizably and statistically significantly worse" in both math and reading.
"Sizably and statistically significantly worse" -- a phrase that many of our kids in Mississippi and across the country can't even spell. But they have the Internet figured out.
So, what to do?
First, every home a school; every parent a teacher. The home-schooling movement is growing among concerned parents in America, as well it should be. Research shows that, on the whole, the longer they are in home-based studies, the more likely students are to outperform their peers.
But not all parents can "home school," given life situations and work demands. Home school anyway, and especially if your child goes to a public and/or secular school. The Hebrews recited the Shema twice a day and many faithful Jews still do today: "Hear O Israel, the Lord is our God the Lord is one. You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your might. And these words, which I am commanding you today, shall be on your heart. And you shall teach them diligently to your sons .... "
The implication, in the best of Hebrew tradition, was that fathers and mothers are responsible for the education of their children. YOU shall teach them, YOU are to be held primarily responsible, not somebody else and most certainly not the government.
Truth is, a lot of other people impact our kids in schools, churches, and popular culture. But parents are supposed to be the pedagogues whose input during the first, best formative years provides an adequate lens through which the child can judge the rest of what she receives educationally for years to come. No matter the educational delivery system, nothing is to obfuscate the input and primacy of the home.
Note it well -- parents are responsible for the good or bad ideas, the excellent or poor achievement of their children. Period.
Second, choose your college well. Most of them, the vast majority of them, are horrible. Pick one that respects God and the Bible and teaches conservatively on issues theological, moral, cultural and economic.
To be honest, that last sentence limits the choices to a proverbial handful. Choose wisely.
Find Dr. Matt Friedeman's blog at "In the Fight." (http://www.inthefight.blogspot.com) Friedeman ([email protected]) is a professor of evangelism and discipleship at Wesley Biblical Seminary (http://www.wbs.edu). He and his wife Mary home school their six children.
© 2005 Agape Press. Used with permission. All rights reserved.