aims to offer the most compelling biblically-based content to Christians on their walk with Jesus. is your online destination for all areas of Christian Living – faith, family, fun, and community. Each category is further divided into areas important to you and your Christian faith including Bible study, daily devotions, marriage, parenting, movie reviews, music, news, and more.

Christian Movie Reviews Christian Blog and Commentary

The Christmas Movie Scorecard

  • Ryan Duncan blogspot for and Ryan Duncan, Entertainment and Culture editor
  • 2015 Dec 04
  • Comments

Everyone has a favorite Christmas movie, but which ones are truly the best? What separates the holiday classic from the cheesy TV special? Well, I am pleased to announce that through rigorous testing and a little too much eggnog, this winter quandary has finally been solved. I give you, the Christmas Movie Scorecard! A defining tally of the best (and worst) features that make up any Christmas film.

The rules are simple: choose any Christmas movie and go down the list, adding and subtracting points as you go. What score will your favorite achieve?

  1. The movie is animated (+10 points)
  2. The movie is stop motion animated (+15 points)
  3. The movie features Santa (+5 points, unless you told your children Santa doesn’t exist, in which case -5 points)
  4. The movie is a musical (+10 points)
  5. The movie is a remake of an older Christmas film (-5 points)
  6. The movie has rhyming narration (+5 points)
  7. The protagonists rescue Santa at some point in the story (+5 points)
  8. The movie stars Tim Allen (-10 points)
  9. There are elves (+10 points)
  10. There are Muppets (+15 points)
  11. There is some kind of winter monster (Choose whether to add or subtract 5 points, you know in your heart what’s right.)
  12. There is a dog dressed as a reindeer (+15 points)
  13. A classic Christmas song originated from this film (+10 points)
  14. A classic Christmas song was the basis for this film (-15 points)
  15. The 3 Wise Men make an appearance (+5 points)
  16. Jesus makes an appearance (+15 points)
  17. Some version of the Christmas story is told (+15 points)
  18. The movie incorporates other holidays (-10 points)
  19. The movie features a crazy relative (+10 points)
  20. The movie is Love Actually (- All the points)

Total Score: __

Christmas Rank

0 – 19: Bah Humbug
20 – 39: Figgy Pudding
40 – 59: Maids a-Milking
60 – 79: Roast Beast
80 – 100: Merry Christmas!

How did your favorite Christmas movie perform? What holiday classics do you enjoy watching this December?

*Published 12/4/2015