- reviewed by Russ Breimeier Copyright Christianity Today International
- 2008 1 Mar
- Wash Me Clean
- Waltz In 3
- Slow Down
Interesting how Shawn McDonald's album titles reflect his current level of artistry. And before you think it, I certainly don't mean to suggest that Simply Nothing was empty or worthless. But much of the songwriting on that 2004 debut was relatively simplistic, especially compared to the development and maturity demonstrated on his 2006 follow-up Ripen. Now comes McDonald's third studio project, and as the title implies,
It's also interesting how each project comes on the heels of a new life change for McDonald. The first album came after kicking his drug addictions and welcoming Christ into his life.
That all makes for an album that's not as overly simplistic as his debut, nor as overly artsy as the second album was at times.
"Wash Me Clean, co-written with Marc Byrd ("God of Wonders"), is a pop-friendly acoustic groove reminiscent of Jack Johnson, with a Psalm-styled prayer for renewal: "Consume my wandering thoughts and renew my mind/And remake, and recreate, and interrupt my life." Psalm 23 inspires the relatively straightforward "Shadowlands," which recalls Shane & Shane with its bouncy acoustic jazz. Likewise, "Time" borrows from Ecclesiastes 3 and the majestic finale "Hallelujah" from the Beatitudes of Jesus.
The beauty of all these tracks is that McDonald doesn't mindlessly recite the texts, but rather adapts them into the context of the songs to craft something that sounds original—no small feat in Christian music. The dreamy acoustic jazz of "Light" is a love song from God that demonstrates this ability to adapt with originality: "I will be the lighthouse in your sea that's guiding you home/And I will be the lamp unto your feet when you roam/Just cling to me, and I'll set you free." From a musical standpoint, producer Chris Stevens uses "Greed" to insert a clever illustration of the stuff that clutters our lives by throwing in banjo, bells, horns, and other instruments to compete for your attention (without distracting too much from the song). And those who enjoy McDonald's quieter, passionate moments like "Lovely" on
There are still some instances where I wish McDonald and Stevens made better artistic decisions with their titles. As good a song as "Clarity" is (co-written with Switchfoot's Jon Foreman) with its pursuit of guidance of truth, the acoustic pop shuffle often sounds too much like John Mayer's hit of the same name. And it seems like McDonald was trying to hard to come up with a clever title for "Waltz in 3." It's a little like calling it "Song with Music in It," considering that all waltzes are in 3. It's a pity that such a richly arranged track with guitars and strings is saddled with such a dumb title.
Quibbles aside, it's nice to see an artist like Shawn McDonald growing with each new album. Two things will improve him even more. He could benefit from more inventive and poetic lyricism. And he could stand to include more instrumental jams, expanding from the sonic textures and grooves to showcase some memorable musicianship along the lines of Dave Matthews or John Mayer. These are simply qualities that would elevate McDonald's work above excellence, and it's not unthinkable for him to get even better. He's already proven here that he has strong