E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS







There was an error processing this request. We cannot subscribe you to newsletters at this time. Please contact technical support with details.
HOME

AVERAGE USER RATING

RATE THIS ARTICLE

  • Email
  • Print
  • Discuss
Search The Bible   
Advanced Search
Product photo

Pastors, Don't Use Mother's Day to Bash Dads

Paul Coughlin

Crosswalk Contributor

A learning season is upon us, and it's worth our time to heed its teaching.

This lesson is the difference between how we handle Mother's Day compared with Father's Day in church. If it's like in years past, it won't be pretty.

This Sunday we will extol the value and benefit of motherhood, which is great. But in some churches, this will be done by degrading Christian husbands, which is not great. "Our pastor makes us husbands get on our knees on Mother's Day and beg for forgiveness. I don't want to do it again this year," one reader tells me. Another writes, "Our minister makes husbands write on paper all the things we've done wrong. Then we're suppose to give it to our wives and pledge that we won't do them anymore."

Most preachers will not be this heavy-handed. They will wait till Father's Day (Sunday, June 18) to tell men how to be better fathers. Of course there's nothing wrong with this message when taken as an isolated event. But when compared with Mother's Day, we'll discover that for some reason many ministers believe that fathers need correction on Father's Day (and Mother's Day) but women don't. Why this double-standard?

Because much of the church sees men as a problem to be fixed when compared to women, not a gender to be appreciated. There's prejudice and bigotry against a man's nature in too many churches, Christian publishing, and on Christian radio (I was a program director of a Christian radio station--I was part of the problem too), all of which have been beating men up for decades.

For example, if there is a problem with their marriage, Christian men have been told by these sources that it is automatically their fault. Dr. James Dobson is one of a few authors brave enough to confront this false message. He writes in Love Must Be Tough that men are saddled with the unrealistic expectation that "any sadness or depression that a woman might encounter is her husband's fault. At least he has the power to eradicate it if he cares enough. In other words, many American women come into marriage with unrealistically romantic expectations which are certain to be dashed. Not only does this orientation set up a bride for disappointment and agitation in the future, it also places enormous pressure on her husband to deliver the impossible...Marital conflict always involves an interaction between two imperfect human beings who share the responsibility to one degree or another." Sadly, Dobson's common sense is drowned out by other and more shrill voices.

I was told as an impressionable and young Christian man in church that I was "irresponsible, thoughtless, and selfish," when compared to women, who are innately more moral and spiritual. I don't know everything about the Bible. But I do know two profound truths: It says a lot about morality and spirituality. Nowhere does it state that women have a corner on both when compared to men. Instead, it tells us that both genders are uniquely and equally made in the image of God. It tells us that both are equally sinful and in need of redemption. There is no privileged gender in God's eyes.

Still, this rose-scented inequality will spread across our country this weekend, creating unintended consequences. Many will hear about the dark side of fatherhood in America, but few if any will hear about motherhood's dark side. How a child is more likely to be physically abused and killed by his mother, not his father. The statistics vary from 65% to more than 80%, which includes adjustments for single mothers. How wives over 40 and with children file for divorce more than husbands (around 66%), and their reason has little if anything to do with abuse or infidelity. How wives are more prone to begin a conversation more harshly than husbands. These aren't exactly family values. Listing these problematic facts of life will likely cause more shock than the facts themselves.

I could create an equally unflattering portrait of wayward fathering, which would include damning facts about fatherlessness and incarceration. But pointing out the ugly in each gender isn't the point of this article. The goal is to explode the myth of gender superiority, create a more biblically sound perspective, and implore today's ministers and lay people to treat each gender with respect and dignity during this important season by pointing out their unique value, which will foster genuine domestic harmony, among other blessings.

Here are some facts that can easily be worked into upcoming sermons about the importance and value of fatherhood. None is derogatory toward mothers but instead points out the complimentary nature of mothers and fathers.

1 | 2 | 3 | Next | All
Most Recent User Comments
niralrussell
5/8/2008 11:54 PM
MyGuide, there are millions of men who do wrong. There are also millions of women who do wrong. The stats are not pretty for either gender. I think the point of the article is that Mother's day celebrates mom, as it should. But it should not do so at the expense of Dad. In the same way, Father's day should celebrate dad without bashing Mom. Many men are doing great. Many are great husbands, brothers, uncles, sons, fathers, etc. Many are responsible. Many are passionate and loving. We who are taking care of our households are getting tired of being told to "step it up" while women get a pass. Being a woman does not make a person smarter, more sensible, or more loving. In God's eyes, the playing field is level, and we ALL have a lot to learn from Him. If you go to your local bookstore, you will see shelves lined with books that celebrate motherhood and womanhood. But in the men's section, you will see books that attempt to teach manhood, as though none of us have arrived.
niralrussell
5/8/2008 11:45 PM
What an amazing article, and how, true!!! While I cannot ignore the extreme difficulty women have faced throughout history, I am growing weary of the man-bashing in the church. Young boys hear this man-bashing, and act as though there is something wrong with being masculine. Sadly, they tend to become more feminine, or they become overly aggressive because they do not understand the good of being a man without apology. I know one thing...my sons are not gonna be a buncha weak-kneed, namby-pamby, squeaky-voice, sitcom-dad types of guys. They are going to be man who if they are verbally bashed, can still strive to be real men -- like Jesus.

Happy Mother's day, Mom!
From your son, the man.
MYGUIDE
5/13/2007 4:14 AM
It is a sad fact that most children never get to see their dads or even sleep in the same house with them. Mothers are responsible for being the primary care for children. I guess any time women are praised, it means men are being bashed. Men need to step up more and I beleive there will be less bad news for them. Society is not making up the stories, reality speaks for itself.
Sign up to post your comments

It's quick and easy to register with Crosswalk.com! Just fill out the short form below. You'll have the opportunity to post comments, and be more involved in our community and forums. Plus, with this one account, you can sign in anywhere in our network of sites displaying the Salem All-Pass logo, including Oneplace.com, Christianity.com, Lightsource.com, Crosscards.com, and more!