E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS








There was an error processing this request. We cannot subscribe you to newsletters at this time. Please contact technical support with details.
Featured Sponsors
HOME

AVERAGE USER RATING

RATE THIS ARTICLE

  • Email
  • Print
  • Discuss
Search The Bible   
Advanced Search
<i>The Secret</i>: New Book, Old Lie

The Secret: New Book, Old Lie

Mark Earley

BreakPoint

What if I promised you that you could make anything happen — anything! — just by wanting it to happen?

You would think I was crazy, and you would be right. So why is a book based on this premise selling so fast that bookstores cannot keep it on the shelves?

Rhonda Byrne’s The Secret has been on the New York Times bestseller list for months, and a DVD version is also selling out everywhere. Byrne is selling the tempting message that anything you want is possible and easy to get.

This isn’t just about keeping an optimistic attitude to improve your life — it goes far beyond that. Byrne says a force called the Law of Attraction guarantees that if you think positive thoughts about what you want, you will get it. “The Universe” will bend over backwards to hand you whatever you wish for: money, a better job, a spouse, anything.

Byrne’s claims are absurd on their face. She swears repeatedly that the Law of Attraction never fails, that it’s as reliable as the law of gravity. So what happens if two people both use “the secret” to make opposite things happen — for instance, if one wanted a sunny day and the other wanted rain?

Somehow, Byrne forgets to address this topic.

But that’s not the worst part. Among all the positive rhetoric are some very ugly concepts. While you are rearranging the universe to suit your own wishes, Byrne claims, you must avoid people who might inspire negative thoughts. So you should never look at overweight people or let sick people tell you about their illness.

Furthermore, if some people are poor, it “is because they are blocking money from coming to them with their thoughts.” (Jesus Christ, she announces, was actually a millionaire). And people involved in tragedies and disasters brought it on themselves. They did not want enough not to “be in the wrong place at the wrong time.”

Friends, I am not exaggerating. It’s all in there.

Tim Watkin reports in the Washington Post, “I watched Bob Proctor... one of the ‘gurus’ Byrne quotes most often, being asked on ‘Nightline’ whether the starving children of Darfur had ‘manifested’ — that is, visualized — their own misery. In utter seriousness, he replied, ‘I think the country probably has.’”

1 | 2 | Next | All
Most Recent User Comments
lighttruth
5/31/2007 3:14 AM
I totally agree with philiprohler. We as human beings have a tendency to base our lives more on what we think, feel, the situations and circumstances that surround us than on what is really true. We have a tendency to be overboard in one area above the rest. God has promised very great things in the Word (that are truly beyond human comprehension - try feeding a whole nation on Manna and Quail for 40 years!) but also has never denied the pain and sufferings of life due to sin in the world that has caused us to become broken fallen people.

I always ask believers and unbelievers every where I am to look at the Word of God as if it were Him talking to us and not us trying to interpret His Words in our finite minds. This book called The Secret is just another book dealing with certain aspects/concepts that maybe in the Word of God but not the whole counsel of God. There lies the balance - go back & check what God has to say about the matter.
treyzamay
5/21/2007 8:07 AM
When I first saw "The Secret," I agreed with the precepts, because doesn't Jesus say to us himself that If we say for the Mountains to be moved, it shall be done? I think as Christians we sometimes don't have enough faith that God, through US allows all of our dreams to come true. I do not agree that there is a "Big Genie" of the Universe...they were sincerely missing something there...GOD is the only power. Also, doesn't the good book say that we are made in his likeness and created in his image? He created US to create GOOD here on the Earth and all for his glory...I think we DO create the bad because of our thought patterns and we DO create good because of our thought patterns...but we need to give credit where credit is due...the glory of God only allows us this privilege. All things are created by God and for God...THAT is where people are mistaken, is when they think it is THEMSELVES, but it is God who created us, and allows us to create using his power through us.
greyman1
5/15/2007 5:52 AM
Looking at the practical implications. A Christian friend of mine recently purchased the book and the shortly afterwards received a very handsome windfall. I mean very handsome.

The question that this then poses is : Is it due to the thought pattern introduced by "The secret" or do you thank God? This is where the crux lies for me. Is it our own doing or do we give God the glory?
Sign up to post your comments

It's quick and easy to register with Crosswalk.com! Just fill out the short form below. You'll have the opportunity to post comments, and be more involved in our community and forums. Plus, with this one account, you can sign in anywhere in our network of sites displaying the Salem All-Pass logo, including Oneplace.com, Christianity.com, Lightsource.com, Crosscards.com, and more!