Caedmon's Call-The Critique
- Wednesday, October 25, 2000
Its hard to know what to expect from a bands third national release.
Especially if its a band that has also recorded several guild CDs for limited distribution and a 6-year-old independent CD that remains a top-seller on grassroots.com.
So what should you expect from Caedmons Calls latest, Long Line of Leavers?
If youre a fan of Caedmons usual folk-pop style, you wont be disappointed. Songs such as Dance, What You Want, and Cant Lose You fit the guitar-driven acoustic sound thats trademark for a band leading the way in the recent revival of folk music. But theres definitely some musical variety on this album, ranging from the Beatlesque Mistake of My Life to a John Michael Talbot cover, Prepare Ye the Way.
Still its the songwriting that impresses me most about this album. Aaron Tate, the writer of many of Caedmons songs, has a gift for blending theology and music in a way that is seldom heard and much needed. He describes the battle between faith and doubt in lyrics that are fierce in their desperation in Prove Me Wrong: Sometimes I fear maybe Im not chosen/Youve hardened my heart like Pharaoh/That would explain why life is so hard for me Cast out my doubts, please prove me wrong/Cause these demons can be so headstrong. And Derek Webb, one of the bands three lead singers and also a regular songwriter, expresses the paradoxical emotions of love in What You Want: I want you just like a hole in my head/But I need you like a meal and a bed.
Serious Caedmons fans, however, may miss the earthy grassroots feel of earlier albums, as Long Line of Leavers has a distinctly more produced sound. And serious musicians may miss the thematic and stylistic unity of their sophomore release, Forty Acres. Leavers has a lack of continuity that showcases the individuality of each song but sometimes makes the CD play more like a collection than a unified album. Nevertheless, Long Line of Leavers is a strong offering from a band with the talent and potential to be a favorite for a long time to come.
Recently on Music
Of Shrimp & PolyesterAsk Roger: How do we know which OT laws to still follow?
A Heart for At-Risk Women7 practical ways you can reflect Christ's love for the abused
A Gossip-Free Zone5 ways you can declare yourself free of spreading strife
What's Up with THAT?The world finds our beliefs incredulous. We should offer answers
Have something to say about this article? Leave your comment via Facebook below!
Example: "Gen 1:1" "John 3" "Moses" "trust"
Listen to Your Favorite Pastors
Add Crosswalk.com content to your siteBrowse available content