- reviewed by Russ Breimeier Copyright Christianity Today International
- 2001 1 Jan
Ah, Five Iron Frenzy — one of Christian music's most unusual and thrilling bands. The octet from Colorado probably always will be considered something of a "cult band," meaning the group's unusual style will always have a fierce and loyal following even though it'll probably never be embraced by the public at large. And fans will simply shrug their shoulders and say, "Their loss," continuing to bounce around to Five Iron's manic ska-rock sound and singing along to their sometimes hilarious, often thought-provoking lyrics. The ska music fad of the mid-to-late '90s has almost passed, however, and it remains to be seen if the ska bands will be able to continue. Inevitably, most of them will fade away if they haven't already. The two exceptions to that are The Supertones, who seem capable of continuing by embracing a hardcore rock sound, and Five Iron Frenzy, whose sound has stretched past basic ska for some time now.
For their fourth full-length studio album,
I love the group's melodies and the band is clearly talented all around, but their greatest strength, in my opinion, is their lead vocalist and primary lyricist, Reese Roper. It's rare for a writer to easily shift from intellectual, gut-wrenching honesty to absurdity. Fans will laugh at the geek anthem "You Can't Handle This" and "Pre-Ex-Girlfriend," which describes a relationship that's over before it starts. Also, "Plan B" is a so-funny-but-true look at slackers who go from day to day in a walking coma, existing but not really living. Contrast those to songs such as "Far, Far Away" and "Farsighted," which both pay tribute to those who persevere in their faith. "Spartan" uses a less common definition of the word to describe the modest and lonely lives some Christians endure. The album's closer, "Eulogy," is one of those songs that's so profound, I'm not sure I've fully grasped the meaning of it. So far, I'm going to venture it's about the danger of letting pride in our lives cause others to stumble in their walk of faith. There's just not enough space here to talk about all the lyrical content of a Five Iron Frenzy album, but I'll summarize by saying that Reese may well be one of the most clever and satirical lyricists in Christian music today, joining the ranks of Ian Eskelin (All Star United), Steve Taylor, and Larry Norman.
If you look at the cover and art design of the new Five Iron album, with all eight members staring somberly in the distance across a desolate plain, it looks as though the band has taken a more serious turn. This is the first album from the band that doesn't feature costumes or cartoons in the booklet. You'll even see a photo of the band's instruments in a bonfire. Fear not — I've been assured that Five Iron Frenzy has no intention of breaking up. They may be displaying their more serious side in some ways, but they still serve it up with a wink, a smile, and a whoopee cushion — how else do you explain an album title taken from a breakdance movie sequel from the mid-1980s? Or Reese's continued use of costumes in concerts (most recently a boy scout's outfit)? Or the sock puppet choir audiences participate in at the shows? With