Against the disturbing advice of her mother (Joanna Kerns), Alison decides to keep the baby. Of course, if she didn’t it wouldn’t be much of a movie, and certainly not a comedy. Ben and Alison begin to develop a romance in spite of their extenuating circumstances. Ben is endearing and trying to become good father/husband material. While in reality it is untenable that the attractive Alison could find very much to like about man-boy Ben, the engaging on-screen chemistry between Heigl and Rogan makes the pair seem more compatible than they would actually be. Rogan plays Ben’s subtle character arch with convincing finesse.
As the film progresses you get the feeling that Ben is not a complete loser, but just a guy who was never shown how to be a man. He truly wants to be the man in Alison’s life but flounders at first. Differences make Alison decide she doesn’t want to just get together because a child is on the way. She points out her control-freak sister and lethargic brother-in-law Pete (Paul Rudd), whom Ben has been palling around with, had a shot gun wedding due to an unplanned pregnancy and subsequently a less-than-happy marriage. There is the typical romantic comedy breakup scene after a big fight, but naturally they work it out in time for the baby’s arrival.
Of course, Ben’s roomies are always around with their vulgar “advice.” The issues surrounding pregnancy and childbirth can allow for some pretty tasteless jokes. And in the case of Knocked Up, the glibness of the title speaks volumes. What could have been a charming comedy about "putting off childish things" is lost in a sea of dirty jokes.
AUDIENCE: Adults (AUTHOR’S NOTE: Please don’t write to Crosswalk and complain that you took your kids to see this movie because it is “pro-life” and has an overall positive message. Read the cautions below and take them seriously.)
CAUTIONS: