Joe McKeever Christian Blog and Commentary

7 Simple Steps for Young Pastors to Select the Right Mentor

  • Joe McKeever

    Joe McKeeverhas been a disciple of Jesus Christ more than 65 years, been preaching the gospel more than 55 years, and has been writing and cartooning for Christian publications more than 45 years. He…

  • Updated Jun 25, 2019

A friend called me out on something I had said about young pastors needing older mentors, and he was right.

“Joe,” he said, “you tell young pastors to find themselves an older pastor as a mentor. But my experience is that many older guys are less committed to Christ than the younger ones. And some of them will scoff at the notion of pastors protecting themselves from temptation with the women, not riding in a car with a woman alone, that sort of thing.”

He wondered if I didn’t want to revise my advice.

I told him I have been blessed by having some godly older pastors in my life, and some of them have made invaluable contributions.  But I’m sure he’s right. 

Just because a man has seniority does not make him a role model, endow him with wisdom, or gift him with a heart full of compassion or a head full of sense.

So, let’s focus on how to choose an older pastor as your advisor, mentor, counselor, and most of all, friend.

1. Ask the Father to lead you.

Your heavenly Father knows them all, knows their history in intimate ways as only the Holy Spirit can, and is more than willing to lead you. God knows you, knows what you need, and loves you more than you love yourself.

This means, of course, that you pay attention to the prompting of His Spirit within you. When His Spirit tells you that someone is wrong, don’t argue; just move on.

2. Consider his character.

Pay attention to how he is respected by those who know you both. Is he compassionate enough to grant you some of his time? Is he mature enough to know you are (in all likelihood) miles behind him in spiritual understanding and in conquest of your self? 

If there is evidence he is lacking in maturity or character, pray for him and seek elsewhere.

3. Ask yourself: do I like and admire this fellow?

It’s not necessary to analyze the reasons why or why not. If you simply do not like him, find yourself resisting his spirit and wanting to be elsewhere, do yourself and him a favor. Don’t try to make a connection there. There are too many other alternatives.

God has a lot of wonderful older pastors who would enjoy some time with you and the privilege of praying for you.

On the other hand, if you would you like to be like him when you, ahem, grow up...that’s a huge component in selecting a mentor.

4. Try to discern: Is God still at work in him?

Can you see God working through him? Or, did he stop growing decades ago?

5. Tiptoe into the relationship by picking his brains briefly.

Don’t call him and ask him to be your life-mentor and meet with you an hour a week for the next few years. Anyone would find the very idea burdensome. 

Call him up and ask him either to meet you for a cup of coffee at some quiet place where you can talk. Or, tell him you’ve got a sermon block on a subject and ask if you could you have 10 minutes of his time to pick his brains on the subject. 

In other words, tiptoe into the relationship. See if the Lord is in this. If this goes well, what you intended for 10 minutes will turn into an hour and you will love it. Your entire day will be better as a result. And if it does not go well, then fine; nothing lost.

6. Over the next few days, ask the Lord if He has someone else for you to contact. 

After all, there’s not a thing wrong with you having several great “older pastor friends” in your corner.

7. Once a relationship is established, plan accountability questions.

Once it’s obvious that the veteran is enjoying these meetings as much as you, ask about a regular schedule with him (whether you use the actual word “mentor” or not).

When you two decide to meet regularly, then discuss what you will do in your sessions. If this is to be a genuine mentoring/discipling time, you might want to develop a few set questions for him to ask you each time, to hold yourself accountable. A missionary friend of mine suggested these:

  • Are you spending quality time in the Word each day?
  • How are your priorities? (My friend said, “The proper order should be God, spouse, children, church.”)
  • How is your inner purity?

I’m going to be 80 years old next Spring. I started preaching the year I graduated from college, and served a church for a couple of years before heading to seminary. 

I desperately needed an older friend to advise and guide me, to give me counsel, to help me with sermons, and to kick my...well, you know. I pray you find that someone. It will undoubtedly benefit you both.

Photo Credit: ©GettyImages/gpointstudio