Responding to "Green Politics," Part Two
- Michael Craven Center for Christ & Culture
- 2007 18 Jun
Does the human population exceed the capacity of the earth and therefore place us in danger of destroying the planet? The answer is simply “no.” The fact is if you allotted 1219 square feet to each person, the entire population of the world would fit into the state of Texas! Try the math yourself: 7,438,152,268,800 square feet in Texas, divided by a world population of 6,100,000,000, equals approximately 1219 square feet per person. The population density of this giant city would be somewhat more than San Francisco and slightly less than the Bronx!
It is true that parts of the world tend to be pretty crowded. But while “overcrowding” may sound frightening, it’s a misleading term that has little to do with the scientific definition of “overpopulation.” People in India are crammed together not because there are too many for the land to hold, but because like people the world over, they prefer urban centers to rural areas. Overcrowding may be a problem, but it’s not overpopulation.
Dr. Jacqueline R. Kasun, economist and the author of The War Against Population: The Economics and Ideology of World Population Control (Ignatius, 1988, 1998) points out that “people do live in crowded conditions, and always have. We cluster together in cities and villages in order to exchange goods and services with one another. But while we crowd together for economic reasons in our great metropolitan areas, most of the world is empty… It has been estimated by [environmental doomsayer] Paul Ehrlich and others that human beings actually occupy no more than 1-3% of the earth’s land surface.”
What about our natural resources? Aren’t the current population levels, which again are admittedly the highest in history, depleting the earth’s forests and other natural resources? Forests are an essential part of the world’s eco-system. We know, for example, that trees inhale carbon dioxide (CO2) and exhale oxygen, which means that they are a first line of defense against air pollution and the specter of “global warming.” Most of us have been led to believe that wanton “deforestation” is commonplace across the globe. However, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) estimates there are currently four billion hectares of forest, covering 30% of the land surface of the earth. Interestingly, this is the same figure as in the 1950s!
In the United States, vast forests cover a third of the land, according to the US Forest Service. That’s equivalent to two-thirds of the amount of land that was forested when the Europeans arrived in the 1600s. This acreage has not declined since 1920. In fact, annual forest growth today is more than 3-1/2 times what it was in 1920.
There has also been great agitation about the “destruction of the tropical rainforests.” Someone has claimed that an area twice the size of Belgium is now being logged worldwide each year, but people don’t realize Belgium could fit into the world’s tropical forests 500 times, and in the meantime, the rest of the world’s trees -- 99.6% of them -- are continuing to grow. FAO and Brazilian government figures suggest that logging takes about 0.2% of forest acreage per year, and in 1993, Brazilian forests covered 58% of the country’s total land area. The deforestation occurring in Brazil cannot be attributed to overpopulation; Brazil has less than half as many people per square mile (31.2) as the world average (101).
Another charge is that human population will inevitably outstrip food and water supplies, not to mention the environmental impact of trying to provide for the “exploding” population. Paul Ehrlich, the Nobel Prize winning immunologist and currently the Bing Professor of Population Studies at Stanford University wrote an influential article that appeared in New Scientist in December 1967. In that article, Ehrlich predicted that the world would experience famines between 1970 and 1985 due to population growth outstripping resources. Ehrlich wrote that “the battle to feed all of humanity is over ... In the 1970s and 1980s hundreds of millions of people will starve to death…” In Ehrlich’s 1990 book entitled (you guessed it), The Population Explosion, he claimed that world grain production peaked in 1986. Wrong. In 1986 about 1.8 million metric tons of cereals (the most important grain) were produced, an increase over previous years, according to the FAO. By 2001, that number had increased to 20.7 million metric tons. That’s an eleven-fold increase in just 15 years!
From 1981 to 1989, grain production per person increased by more than 5%. Since then, it’s increased another 4% more per person. Yet we haven’t had to plow under the face of the earth to get this extra food. In 2001, 304 million acres were used to grow the world’s cereals, slightly less than in 1968 when Ehrlich’s first book appeared and far less than the 330 million acres used in the peak year of 1991. The figure that counts the most, however, is that calories available per person reached an all-time high of 2,800 by 1999, up from 2,371 in 1968. We are finally growing enough calories per person to keep the world’s population well fed -- if those calories were evenly distributed, which is not an environmental problem but a political problem.
Also according to the FAO, world food supplies exceed requirements in all world areas, amounting to a surplus approaching 50% in 1990 in the developed countries, and 17% in the developing regions. “Globally, food supplies have more than doubled in the last 40 years ... between 1962 and 1991, average daily per capita food supplies increased more than 15% ... at a global level, there is probably no obstacle to food production rising to meet demand,” according to FAO documents prepared for the 1996 World Food Summit. The fact is [Western] technological advances have enabled us to produce more food on less land.
Acclaimed American economist Julian Simon points out:
After I investigated case after case of phenomena which the doomsters said were getting worse because of increasing scarcity and population growth, and found instead that they were getting better … In short, humankind has evolved into creators and problem-solvers. Our constructive behavior has counted for more than our using-up and destructive behavior, as seen in our increasing length of life and richness of consumption. This view of the average human as builder conflicts with the view of the average human as destroyer which underlies the thought of many doomsdayers.
What Julian Simon unwittingly recognizes is the imago deo of human beings who, unlike the animals, are endowed with unique God-given abilities to carry out their stewardship responsibilities related to creation. Even within a fallen world mankind is still able to employ his God-given intellect and creativity in order to mitigate the effects of the Fall. This, in no way, suggests that we should consume without regard for the environment because we trust in human ingenuity to overcome our abuses. It means that those who believe humans are simply a “more clever monkey” fail to acknowledge the fact of humanity’s primacy and responsibility within creation. Furthermore, when mankind lives in accordance with the biblical definition of himself as a specially appointed steward; both society and the environment experience the greatest possible benefit.
Here to view Michael's Crosswalk.com blog
Here to give Michael feedback on this article
Here to request e-mail delivery of Michael's weekly commentary
Here to subscribe to Michael's free podcast
S. Michael Craven is the Founding Director of the Center for Christ & Culture, a ministry of the National Coalition for the Protection of Children & Families. The Center for Christ & Culture is dedicated to renewal within the Church and works to equip Christians with an intelligent and thoroughly Christian approach to matters of culture in order to recapture and demonstrate the relevance of Christianity to all of life. For more information on the Center for Christ & Culture, additional resources and other works by S. Michael Craven visit: www.battlefortruth.org.
Michael lives in the Dallas area with his wife Carol and their three children.
© 2007 S. Michael Craven