Spiritual Life

Is the Great Church Seating Debate Missing the Point?

Ever feel like Christian discussions get bogged down by turning good ideas into rigid rules, such as the recent debate about where married couples should sit in church? This insightful piece cuts through the noise, revealing how a deeper...
Nov 20, 2026
My Crosswalk Follow topic Follow author
Generational Church ©Getty Images/ skynesher

Listen or Read Below:

Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

We’ve got a real tendency to miss the forest for the trees when it comes to Christian dialogue. That was certainly the case a few days ago when everyone seemed to be in an uproar over whether or not you could sit together at church. That’s where I’m headed, but first, I want to build us a foundation for thinking through these things.

“Good families eat dinner together every night.”

You hear that phrase when you’re taking one of those marriage and family type classes in college. They roll out all the statistics and make a compelling case for the benefit of this practice. You store that away and know that when you have your own family, this will be non-negotiable.

You get married. You have a kid.

To provide for that spouse and child, you have to take a job delivering packages for UPS. Meanwhile, your kid gets signed up for an extracurricular activity at school, and if they’re going to eat, it’ll have to be at 5:00. You don’t get home until 6:30 most nights.

You don’t get to eat dinner together every night… or really any weeknight.

You feel like a massive failure, and you worry that your marriage is going to fall apart, your kid is going to end up being a serial killer, and everyone at church is going to expose what a horrible parent you are and how all of this is your fault because you didn’t prioritize eating family dinners together.

I made the fear a little A-to-Z there, but I truly believe this is how many of us think within the church. We take a good idea, turn it into a law in itself, and miss the whole point.

Adventures in Missing the Point

Let’s talk about the idea that good families eat dinner together every night. First, we might say that it’s already loaded because you’ve put a moral word like “good” into a practice that is amoral. When Bonnie and Clyde were holed up at a little house in Joplin, MO, they cooked red beans and cabbage with Clyde’s brother Buck and his wife Blanche. It was like a family reunion except that Clyde was wanted for murder. Good families eat together, right?

I think what we’re trying to say here is that there are benefits to a child’s life, and to a marriage, when a family eats together. But it probably doesn’t have as much to do with sitting down at 5:30 on a Tuesday night and chowing down on mom’s spaghetti—good as it is. What’s actually happening here is that you have a specific time when a family can talk and stay connected.

Some of the studies I’ve read indicate that if links are already strong, then a family meal only serves to strengthen them. But there isn’t much benefit if those relationships are already weak.

All that to say, the professor who said that it’s good for families to eat together isn’t wrong. But the bigger point here is that it’s good for families to talk together and communicate frequently—one way to do that is at a family meal. If you can’t do that family meal for some reason, don’t give up. Instead, find another way to stay connected with your family more frequently.

Now let’s talk about families sitting together at church…

About That Article

I’ll admit that I didn’t read the original article when it had a more forceful title. I read the toned-down version. I think that caused me to bristle less than those who first read it. But even still, I thought people seemed to be getting a bit too worked up over this thing.

The Gospel Coalition (Australia) posted an article in which its contributor, Dave Moore, argued that married couples should be “others”- oriented when considering where they should sit. He said it this way:

So here’s our take: spouses, consider whether you always sit together in church. That might be a radical idea for some. Please don’t hear me suggesting that sitting with your spouse is wrong. However, as Julie and I discussed it, we thought it was worth calling Christian couples to re-imagine what it’s like walking into church on your own, and then to think of church less like a date and more like a deployment.

It might have been the provocative title that set people on edge. Or it might have been lines like this one: “dividing ourselves for the sake of others is the most beautiful picture of Christian unity.” That was a line Griffen Gulledge took issue with in his response article, "When Families Sit Together in Church: The Missional Opportunity."

Gulledge argues that worshiping together is already part of the church’s mission, since children learn how to worship by watching their parents. In his mind, a great way to welcome people is to invite them to sit with their families rather than making a habit of sitting apart.

That’s similar to Stephen McAlpine’s response too. In his "Spouses, Sit Together at Church," he argues that families are already split up enough. The best way to connect with potentially lonely people is to linger after the service and invite them into ordinary life throughout the week.

These are fair responses. But I can’t help but think that we might still be missing the point. The heart of Moore’s concern is that there are lonely people in our churches. And in the family of God, that shouldn’t be the case. That’s the heart.

He probably didn’t do himself any favors by making an imperative out of his idea. It basically became “A couple concerned about loving others won’t sit together on Sunday morning”. That’s just another version of “Good families eat dinner together every night.” The tragedy is that the discussion then centers on “sitting together,” and it moves away from the heart of the article.

But if I’m being honest, I think we could just as easily overextend those article responses too. Is it always the most missional thing to sit with your family and invite someone into your row? We could easily turn either of these into the conclusion that “Good Christian couples sit together at church.” Well… maybe not always.

This brings me to my take on the whole ordeal.

Love God and Sit Where You Want

I’ve spent a good chunk of my ministry working with teens. All-or-nothing thinking is kind of their jam. They tend to swing from one extreme to the other. That’s not to dog on them, by any means. I love students. But that’s just how we humans tend to learn. Age tempers us.

Christians have been disagreeing with each other for a couple thousand years now. But we’ve only had about twenty years to learn how to do it on social media. In that sense, we’re still basically teenagers. (To be clear, I’m not saying any of the response articles are juvenile or anything like that—they are reasonable and well-written. My point is about the whole of the discussion and how we typically argue about these things).

What I’m trying to say is that teenagers tend to think in pretty black-and-white terms. They often ask “is it okay if I?” questions. Can I kiss my girlfriend? How far is too far? Is it okay if I play GTA6? Yes? No? But wisdom usually frames things differently.

That’s where I often use a bit of Augustine (or my butchered version of Augustine) to help them think through some of these questions. I typically misquote him a little by saying, “Love God, and do what you want.” Technically, he just said, “Love, and do what you will.”

His point is that the same action can be good or evil depending on the love behind it. One guy may look harsh because he loves, while another looks pleasant but he’s filled with vice. Love is what matters. And that’s what I try to get teenagers (or adults) to think through when trying to answer some of these tough questions.

I could see how Dave Moore and his wife could be motivated by love and decide that they aren’t going to sit together on a Sunday morning. That’s beautiful. But you could also do it without love, and it not be a beautiful thing.

The same is true for sitting with your wife. I could see inviting someone into your family and having them sit in your row being motivated out of love. It could also be motivated out of annoyance, by wanting to look nice and friendly, by wanting to look missional, and a million other things that aren’t nearly as beautiful.

That’s why I say of this whole discussion: Love, and do what you will.

It’s important to help people feel loved and welcomed. How you do that may not always be perfectly clear. And love does mean you sacrifice at times. It might mean you sacrifice sitting with your spouse or your friends. Or it might mean you sacrifice the opportunity to engage with someone because your spouse really needs you to sit with them this Sunday.

Love, and sit where you will.

Mike Leake is husband to Nikki and father to Isaiah and Hannah. He is also the lead pastor at Calvary of Neosho, MO. Mike is the author of Torn to Heal and Jesus Is All You Need. His writing home is https://mikeleake.net and you can connect with him on Twitter @mikeleake. Mike has a new writing project at Proverbs4Today.

Originally published November 20, 2026.

My Crosswalk Follow topic Follow author

SHARE